10 Interview Mistakes Smart People Keep Making (and How to Fix Them)

You’ve got the skills. Your resume is solid. You’re landing interviews, but the offers aren’t coming.

It’s not because you’re unqualified. It’s because no one ever taught you how to interview effectively. Or maybe you’re thinking, “I’ve got this. I’m great at interviewing,” even though you haven’t practiced in years.

Here are 10 common interview mistakes and how to avoid them so you can show up with confidence and get the results you deserve.

1. Winging It Because “I’ll Sound More Natural”

You tell yourself, “If I prepare too much, I’ll sound scripted.” The reality is the opposite. Without practice, nerves take over and your answers ramble or fall flat.

Fix it: Rehearse out loud. Practice with a friend or coach who can give you feedback. The candidates who sound natural are the ones who practiced until it felt easy.

2. Talking in Rambles Instead of Stories

You want to cover every detail, so your answers become long and wandering. The interviewer tunes out before you get to the point.

Fix it: Use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to organize your answers into concise, memorable stories.

3. Falling Into Negative Talk

When asked, “Tell me about your biggest mistake at [Company],” you overshare, get defensive, or focus on what went wrong.

Fix it: Own the mistake briefly, focus on what you learned, and pivot to how you apply that lesson today. This shows growth and self-awareness without dragging the conversation down.

4. Mishandling Why You Left a Job

Explaining why you left a company, especially if it wasn’t on your terms, is tricky. Many candidates stumble here and end up oversharing or sounding bitter.

Fix it: Simple honesty is the best policy. Say, “I was laid off” or “I was terminated.” Stop there. Chances are the interviewer won’t press for details. If they do, share a brief, professional explanation and pivot to what you’re excited about next.

5. Treating It Like a Q&A, Not a Conversation

You answer their questions but don’t engage beyond that. The interview feels stiff and one-sided.

Things to avoid: answering with short yes/no responses, failing to ask your own questions, or waiting passively for the next prompt. These habits make the conversation feel formal and transactional.

Fix it: Approach it as a two-way conversation. Prepare thoughtful questions that show curiosity about the role and the company. This helps you build rapport and leaves a stronger impression.

6. Over-Focusing on Your Resume

You repeat what’s on your resume instead of showing how you think and communicate.

Fix it: Prepare to talk about experiences and results in a conversational way. Share insights that aren’t word-for-word from your resume to add depth to your story.

7. Not Preparing for Behavioral Questions

You freeze when asked, “Tell me about a time you disagreed with your boss” or “How do you handle conflict?”

Fix it: Anticipate common behavioral questions and have 3–5 STAR stories ready. These can be adapted to fit a variety of scenarios.

8. Giving Rushed or Overly Brief Answers

You’ve been warned not to ramble, so you give one-sentence replies that sound flat and fail to showcase your abilities.

Fix it: Find the middle ground. Add just enough context and detail to make your answers engaging without overloading the interviewer. Rapport matters. This is your chance to show how you can connect and communicate naturally, even under pressure.

9. Showing Frustration With Past Employers

When talking about past roles, you let bitterness slip into your tone. Even subtle negativity can raise red flags for hiring managers.

Fix it: Keep your tone positive and forward-looking. Frame challenges as learning experiences and focus on what you’re looking for in your next role.

10. Not Researching the Company or Role

You’re caught off guard when they ask, “What excites you about our mission?” or “Why do you want this role?”

Fix it: Spend 30 minutes researching their website, recent news, and job description. Be ready to show how your skills align with their goals.

The Bottom Line
You control more of the interview outcome than you realize. Avoiding these mistakes is the first step. The next is preparing smarter so you can walk in with confidence and leave with an offer.

Ready to Take Control of Your Next Interview?

Stop guessing what went wrong and start preparing the right way.

🎯 Join my free training: “Stop Winging It – 3 Interview Prep Moves That Actually Work.”
Seats are limited — don’t miss your chance to get the skills that will set you apart.